Joseph, I have just finished reading the paper and watching the testimony, and I agree with you, Berenson is not a trustworthy source, and those tweets I copied above are a misunderstanding of both the paper and what he said in the video. Thanks for the heads up.
As you say, the ‘peak’ in a few weeks was mentioned in the paper and video, and refers to initial peak before suppression strategy has fully kicked in. It’s not implying anything about end of lockdowns since its with the assumption that suppression interventions are continued until vaccine arrives. Also, further peaks are anticipated if controlled relaxation/restart of interventions is undertaken whilst they wait for the vaccine. So he’s not even committed to a single, final peak. And the death total ranges from 5,600 to 48,000 for GB in the paper for the measures we are currently applying, so substantially less than 20,000 is not a totally new idea.
Me too.
A couple of things I am wondering:
- In the video evidence Ferguson suggested half to 2/3 of those who die would have died relatively soon anyway, such that those people would not affect ‘excess mortality’. I’m wondering why the death rates in the back of the paper are not adjusted for that? Isn’t excess mortality the relevant statistic here?
- The death totals in the paper (Table 4) are for a 2-year period. Should not these be reduced to account for a more realistic time wait for the vaccine (12-18 months)?
- He said the R0 number (measure of transmissibility) has been revised upwards to 3. The reported results in the paper considered 2 to 2.6 (Table 4). Looking at the trend, higher R0 means higher death, and it’s hard to see how he would predict <20000 from the trend with R0=3. Perhaps he is accounting for the above 2 points, or something else?
That said, I’m still very doubtful that lockdowns is the side of caution here, considering the potential human cost of economic damage.
An interesting website is the European Mortality statistics. Presumably, we should expect the Covid-19 deaths to reflect some excess mortality in the charts:
So far it’s not looking like it, though Italy shows some rise but well within seasonal variations. Perhaps people will argue that this is because the lockdowns are working / it will take a bit more time for things the reach relevant magnitude?